A recent decision of the Irish Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) provides important guidance on how Employer of Record (EOR) arrangements may be viewed under Irish employment law. While EOR structures have become increasingly popular for international businesses seeking to hire employees in Ireland without establishing a local entity, Irish legislation does not expressly recognise the EOR model. The decision therefore offers a valuable indication of how these arrangements may be characterised in practice.
The background
The case involved an employee engaged as a visual effects supervisor through an EOR provider. The employee carried out her day-to-day duties for a third-party organisation, while her employment contracts were signed with the EOR provider. Following the end of her engagement, she brought various employment-related claims, including claims relating to redundancy, notice and payment entitlements.
The EOR provider argued that it was the employee’s legal employer under a series of fixed-term contracts and that the employment relationship ended simply because the final fixed-term contract expired. The employee, meanwhile, maintained that the organisation for whom she performed her day-to-day work should be regarded as her true employer.
WRC finds EOR arrangement constituted agency work
A significant aspect of the decision was the WRC’s consideration of the EOR structure itself. The Adjudicator concluded that the arrangement fell within the statutory definition of agency work and characterised the EOR provider as an employment agency. Importantly, however, the WRC also confirmed that the EOR provider remained the employee’s employer for the purposes of the complaints before it.
In reaching this conclusion, the Adjudicator accepted that the client company exercised day-to-day operational control and supervision over the employee’s work. However, the WRC considered this to be consistent with an agency work model and not sufficient to transfer employer status away from the EOR provider.
Claims rejected
Having examined the contractual arrangements and the circumstances of the engagement, the WRC rejected the employee’s claims under redundancy, minimum notice, wage and TUPE-related legislation. The Adjudicator accepted that the fixed-term contract had expired in accordance with its terms and that the statutory claims advanced were not made out on the facts.
While the employee was unsuccessful in her claims, the wider significance of the decision lies in the WRC’s treatment of the EOR model itself.
Wider implications for businesses using EOR services
The decision will be of particular interest to multinational employers that rely on EOR arrangements to engage workers in Ireland. Previous commentary from Irish employment lawyers has highlighted uncertainty regarding how Irish courts and employment bodies would classify these arrangements because there is no specific legislative framework governing EOR providers.
By characterising the arrangement as agency work, this creates a significant risk to the end user that they will be deemed the employer for the purpose of any claims by an employee under the Unfair Dismissals Acts.
Fuente: Crowe